PDA

View Full Version : Medal Of Honor, and Sgt. Peralta


Neon Pink Shoehorn
10-14-2008, 10:17 PM
It used to be that if you smothered a grenade, you'd get the Medal of Honor.

Sgt. Peralta, however, was shot in the face before he smothered a grenade. The Navy and Marine Corps recommended that he be awarded it posthumously. But Defense secretary Robert Gates chose not to recommend him, because his headshot was lethal, and he could not have possibly conciously covered the grenade. Instead, his family is awarded the lesser Navy Cross.

What bothers me is that his citation for the Navy Cross reads as though he did do it on purpose. To me, it seems like a farce. If he did do it on purpose, as his comrades say, then he should receive it. If he didn't, why award him anything?

rabble, rabble.

Sock Full of Boiled Dimes
10-14-2008, 11:20 PM
The Marines are pretty pissed about this.

jariten
10-15-2008, 12:15 AM
The Marines are pretty pissed about this.

As they should be...though the blame lies on the committee as well as Gates (who I respect to great ends so am a bit biased.) The Navy and Marine Corp nominated, with congressional approval, a member of their ranks for this award that no one desires and it was overturned by bureaucrats.

A shame.
Shame.